| ||||||||||
Christianity Versus IslamWritten by: GohanSS3 Christianity and Islam are two of the most widely recognized and widely practiced religions in the world. Islams and Christians have many things in common, as well as various opinions on the application of religion in the day-to-day environment. What is each religion and how does one refer to God? What is the nature, purpose, and plan of each God? What is each religion’s view on the “Spirit” and of Jesus Christ? Both Christianity and Islam have a written book by which to live and only pray to one God. The difference between the two is the character of their sacred books, the religion’s effect on mankind, and their views of God and Christ. The term “Islam” refers to a submission to God or “a total way of life.” The followers of Islam worship Allah, meaning “The God,” who is also referred to as Wise, Merciful, and All-knowing. A Christian, however, is a disciple of Jesus Christ, or “a living sacrifice.” Christians refer to God as the Heavenly Father (meaning “Eternal”), Almighty, and Lord of Hosts. While both religions have Holy scriptures, the points portrayed in each are very different. Christians use the Bible, which is divided into New and Old Testaments, and written under the guidance of the Holy Spirit. The Islamic version of the Bible is Al Qur'an which is composed of one-hundred fourteen suras (units). The Qur’an was dictated to Muhammad by Angel Gabriel and is considered their link to God. The nature of each God can be summarized in two short sentences: the first describing the nature of Allah, and the second the Heavenly Father. Allah is one; He does as He pleases. This means that Allah begets no one, has not begotten, and there is no one like Him. God is our Father. This phrase refers to Jesus as His physically and spiritually begotten Son. God’s plan is to bring all humans into the image of Jesus as His divine children. Islams believe everyone is sinless at birth with a capacity for unlimited moral and spiritual progress through belief in God. Conversely, as Christians everyone is sinless at birth, but prone to sin. Only the grace of God and the gift of His Holy Spirit can inspire humans to surrender their evil ways for good. The believers of Allah, are “His slaves,” and their concept of success is “to hear and to obey.” In contrast, Christian believers are “the children of God,” and their concept for success is to “Love God and your neighbors as yourself.” The Islam religion states that prayer should occur five times on the day of congregation. In opposition, the Christian religion states that prayer should be done alone and in secret. Another big distinction is that of personal justice and reprimanding enemies. The Bible says to “love your enemies and do good to those that hate you,” whereas the Qur’an says to “fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you.” Christian beliefs state that God is the “Holy” Spirit, and can create angels made of Spirit. The Islam beliefs directly disagree with this, stating that a spirit is an angel or created attribute. Under these beliefs God is not the spirit. Both the Islam and the Christian religions believe in Jesus Christ. However, Islams believe He was a prophet of God, but a phantom was crucified in his place on the cross. In direct opposition to this, Christians believe Jesus was the “one-of-a-kind” Son of the Supreme God, begotten by the Heavenly Spirit. Christ descended from Heaven, became human, and died to demonstrate God’s love for us. He is our link to God, experienced through the Holy Spirit. While many of the teachings of these religions conflict, we can clearly see the similarities in the two faiths. Each one gathers knowledge from the Bible and the Qur’an and applies it to every day life in order to gain righteousness. I believe that the best summary of the beliefs of Christians is the following sentence: “God is our Father, love him with all your heart and your neighbor as yourself.” A summary of the Islam beliefs is as follows: “Allah is one, hear Him and obey.”
|
| breeze_whisper 2001-11-28 05:00AM | |
|
Dear Matt, I have read your essay and I was wandering how did you build your contrast? About Islam especially, where the information you got by Muslims or read books of the subject? And if I may ask, did you read parts of the Qura'an? I believe there are faults of describing Islam. As a Muslim my self, I think the essay is good, but too brief in explaining each Christianity and Islam in contrast, with some faults in describing the Islamic belief. The points I have remarks on are the following: 1. The sentence "His slaves". 2. "Concept of success to hear and obey". 3. To fight who fight you. 4. "Spirit is an angel created attribute". 5. "A phantom was crucified in his place on the cross". May I suggest you to go back to your books and make sure of those points? Some of those points depend on the difference between the 2 languages. The word "abd" in Arabic would be more appropriate to be translated as "worshiper" to English. The meaning of "abd" is not being a degrade slave, "abd" in arabic related to religious Islamic concepts that gives the meaning of a "worshipper". As in the concept of Islam is yes to obey Allah's rules to gain heaven. But the way it is projected means that if you do not obey then you will go straight to hell. That is not the case; you are punished for your sins and rewarded for your good deeds. The concept of islam is we are here on earth to worship Allah, worshiping Allah does not only mean prayers in Islam, but it also means to work for developing your self, to live a good life, to study and gain knowledge, to help your community, to be a successful person, to deliver islam to others. All these points are under worship concept, so as a result what you are really doing is helping your self. That is what worshipping is all about. It is not just "hear and obey". You have taken only a part of the concept "to fight the ones who fight you". Yes islam calls a muslim to fight when they are injusticed, which means to fight to defend your self. As Muhammed says you fight for Allah, to defend your self, your family, and your property. This is the concept of "fight" in spiritual level. So it is more to be self-defense. Still Allah ask muslims to forgive when they are wronged, and this is evidenced in the following verses of Qura'an: *"Those who spend (of that which Allah hath given them) in ease and in adversity, those who control their wrath and are forgiving toward mankind; Allah loveth the good" [Surah: The Family of Imran, verse: 134] *"And we prescribed for them therein: The life for the life, and the eye for the eye, and the nose for the nose, and the ear for the ear, and the tooth for the tooth, and for wounds retaliation. But whose forgoeth it (in the way of charity) it shall be expiation for him. Whoso judgeth not by that which Allah hath revealed: such are wrong-doers." [surah: The Table Spread, verse:45] Here is an invitation to fight back for your right, but then appealing the human senses for forgiveness. It is known that a person who is angry by an act of injustice cannot forgive, therefore fight was first mentioned, but then after the wave of negative feelings, forgiveness is projected appealing to the senses. Reasonably you cannot ask a man who is done injustice and angry for it to forgive, but you can furnish the idea of forgiveness gradually. Allah says you can fight back for your justice, but it is better that you forgive because Allah loves the forgivers. Now discussing the "spirit" in spiritual level, in Islam the spirit we are asked not to define. It is one of Allah's secrets: *"They are asking thee concerning the Spirit. Say: The spirit is by command of my Lord, and of knowledge ye have been vouchsafed but little." [Surah: Al-Isra, verse:85] As for saying angels are the attributes for spirit and God is not the spirit it is not correct, this could be explained in semantically level. There is a difference between "ROH" and "RAWH". "ROH" is the human spirit but "RAWH" is another case. Allah uses "RAWH" in different terms. Linguistically, there are different uses for the Arabic word "RAWH" in Qur'an, it refer either to: 1. Allah: "Go, O my sons, and ascertain concerning Joseph and his brother, and despair not of the Spirit of Allah. Lo! non despaireth of the Spirit of Allah save disbelieving folk." [Surah: Joseph, verse: 87] 2. Inspiration, which is the act of inspiring done by Gabriel: "He sendeth down the angels with the Spirit of His command unto whom He will of His bondmen, (saying): Warn mankind that there is no God save Me, so keep your duty unto Me." [Surah: The Bee, verse: 2] 3. The angel Gabriel, as a carrier of the inspiration from Allah: "And verily We gave Moses the Scripture and We caused a train of messengers to follow after him, and We gave unto Jesus, son of Mary, clear proofs (of Allah's Sovereignty), and We supported him with the holy Spirit. Is it ever so, that, when there cometh unto you a messenger (from Allah) with that which ye yourselves desire not, ye grow arrogant, and some ye disbelieve and some ye slay?" [Surah: The Cow, verse: 87] The last point to be discussed the story of Jesus being crucified. The Islamic version of the story says that the man, who is one of Christ pupils, reported against Christ to the king. The king ordered to execute Jesus. When the king and his soldiers went to carry out the sentence, Allah made his pupil who reported against him, look like Christ, and he got crucified instead of Jesus. | |
| [Digital^Dude] 2006-05-01 08:27PM | No Rating |
|
you know wat?? u've gotta listen to Muhammad Ibrahim's lectures on Christianity and Islam... Really!! --------------------- [Digital^Dude]® | |
| PlanetPapers.com | Contact Me | Copyright © 2006 | Privacy Policy | Add to Favorites |